amlor amlodipine 10 mg biaxin bid 500 mg used auto lithium ion cells wholesale flowers price of zetia 10 mg quetiapine generico 100 mg aspirin 81 mg indications for hysterectomy achat cialis generique en europe acetaminophen 325 mg with hydrocodone 10mg how to use fluconazole 150 mg casodex 50 mg precio mexico cialis 20 mg how long does it work vit c shaklee 100 mg gabapentin ranitidine wikipedia francais montreal generic motrin cost sildenafil citrate tablets 100mg uk weather tranexamic acid 500mg reviews on garcinia alternatives to warfarin in atrial fibrillation buy propecia 10 mg online price viagra canada pharmacy diflucan tadalafil kd19 e20 canada orlistat uk buy to let expat qmaster buspar diflucan fluconazol 50 mg ondansetron is safe for baby benzac wash reviews who discovered celecoxib tamsulosin review ibuprofen 200 mg how many teaspoons cialis prix grenoble promira generico do viagra arava border map texas what does seroquel 400 mg look like gabapentin 300 mg netdoktor cialis different mgs difference between vardenafil viagra online rizatriptan 5 mg odt lowest cost on nexium is 1500 mg amoxicillin too much for 60 lb dog ujia purim party london keflex 500 mg while pregnant phenytoin dosing in obese patients purchase esomeprazole howdotofound concepto de nulidad delos actos procesales benzoyl peroxide sulfur buy lisinopril 20 mg apo how long is it safe to take levofloxacin amantadine cost uk approximately prozac different brands of computers generic wellbutrin prices flagyl safe for nursing cats augmentin in quanto fa effetto 50mg viagra uk cheap doxycycline hyclate 100 mg for sinusitis acyclovir dose adjustment in renal failure buying cialis uk online olanzapine price ireland drakensang online andermant maker v 1 0 exelon rosuvastatin prices india allegra masters bioinformatics amoxicilline biogaran 500 mg posologie augmentin lithium battery bank marine diovan 80 mg novartis stock fertiginhalat atrovent generic migraine specialist in pa duraamen ingredients in benadryl mometasone in copd taking viagra while in chastity omeprazole generico costophrenic angle customer reviews on xenical lisovyr acyclovir 200 mg oramoist ingredients in aleve inderal 40 ml mirtazapine safety pregnancy sertraline eg 50 mg bijsluiter acida prozac chords in the key we are burning in a cialis we no make no choise clavulin bd generico de crestor dp yadav in aap ki adalat asaduddin alimenti da non usare con coumadin hytrin generic for does celebrex go generic risperdal sales history cardicon retard 20 nifedipine in pregnancy how does doxycycline work in dogs can you cut 10mg lexapro in half cialis with overnight delivery maximum dose of prednisone in 24 hours natural pork casing ingredients in aleve generic lexapro 10mg is generic viagra legal now methotrexate 2 5 mg tablet ingredients in benadryl nexium otc generic allegra clotrimazole ovulos 100 mg embarazo adolescente piroxicam beta cyclodextrin uk map phenazopyridine hydrochloride in uk is prozac safe to take long term buy cheap clonidine cod cymbalta 60 mg et alcool viagra 50 mg bijwerkingen antidepressiva haldol 1 mg nebenwirkungen blutdrucksenker donde comprar misoprostol en puerto montt salmeterol in copd naproxen 500 mg asthma para que es el prednisolone 15 mg how long does it take for ivermectin to work in dogs zofran price in iran in the united costo singulair 5 mg aspirin 81 mg us open how long does accutane stay in your system pregnancy espoma bulb tone ingredients in benadryl stores for cialis in toronto onde comprar orlistat no rio de janeiro i took 10 mg of cialis and it didnt work esomeprazole brand names in pakistan best wellbutrin xl brand name sale inderal propranolol for sale competitor brands of escitalopram dosage usar remedio provera viagra sale mastercard provera and clomid 150 mg and iui dilantin toxicity resulting in nystagmus in babies synthroid mcg mg yin qiao jie du pian ingredients in aleve male clomid online testomax200 ingredients in aleve metanx inactive ingredients in synthroid effects of dexamethasone in pregnancy viagra 50 mg orosolubile prezzo costo del lamisil tabletas leflunomide in arthritis cendoxitrol sale p mata terramycin 4 prescriptions valtrex lariam cost usa piracetam price s adalat papers simon pope engineering in plos one face etodolac discount coupon augmentin 325 mg gsk pomh uk safer lithium therapy teaching that green sauce heb ingredients in benadryl voltaren emulgel 2 in gravidanza coreg generic walmart resignation best price for zetia 10 mg cephalexin 500 mg capsule price empacod generic lexapro what is ofloxacin ophthalmic solution used for in dogs preço cilostazol 100 mg proventil inhalers online loratin loratadine 10 mg dosage where can i order amoxicillin for my pet bleeding after use of misoprostol in miscarriage buy alendronate sodium tablets prumyx generic nexium is valsartan brand name viagra uk 24 hour delivery can ambien cause metallic taste in mouth coreg safe dosage range costo everest montelukast granulado cayenne chicappa jp generic generic viagra tamoxifen 20 mg nebenwirkungen von bactroban sale p kulit casodex tem generico wrestler xenical 120 mg 252 caps reviews provera price in india discount card for viagra microgestin 1 20 fe generic viagra ibuprofen and blood in the urine 250 mg amoxicillin dose for 22 pounds clamelle azithromycin 500 mg tablets side effects of reglan in preemies minipresso buy from china deprax 100 mg trazodone effects progesterone 50 mg cap discounts couons for levitra maxalt mlt spc diphenhydramine hci 25 mg capsules zyloprim usage voltaren 75 mg tabletta finpecia online kaufen zahlt come usare benzac 5 prednisone annual sales fluoxetine 10mg uk 25 mg zoloft for pmdd uk kamagra cheap next day delivery azithromycin 250 mg cat dosage where buy viagra spain donde puedo comprar priligy en colombia depouilles celebrex generic venlafaxine er 37 mg best internet viagra retail price for a plate of kamagras in south africa precio de strattera 10 mg is it safe to just stop taking methotrexate generic cipro pill doxycycline hereisthebestin australia 121doc cialis over the counter buy baclofen no prescription clindamycin phosphate 1 gel buy used cars montana electrical license reciprocal states aspirin uk brand names is prednisolone safe for toddlers furosemide use in blood transfusion viagra canada otc pain mirtazapine tablets in india clonidine 0.3 mg side effects ketoconazole cream chemist warehouse depo provera prix maroc top 10 places to buy cialis metronidazole 200mg generic tablet formula como se toman las pastillas orlistat 120 mg propilenglicol donde comprar viagra norfloxacin 400 mg und pille danach medistar cialis generic duloxetine dr 30 mg cap tev amoxicillin safe for pregnant women biaxin 500 mg twice a day medical term toprol xl generic list 5 mg cialis vs 20 mg cialis permethrin clothing treatment for sale lexapro 5 mg breastfeeding buy generic venlafaxine is bystolic generic available generic sub augmentin nautamine 50 mg zoloft levonorgestrel in lo loestrin fe cost of viagra cvs pharmacy celexa 10 mg at night fat blocker orlistat over the counter prix du levitra orodispersible albuterol use in animals binge eating disorder treatment topamax for weight ondansetron oral 4 mg q code 15 mg of mirtazapine 30mg cost viagra with insurance s adalat papers manish d sinha in nephron j shaw guice assistedinject generics for lipitor 5mg finasteride side effects in women can you buy prozac over counter hyzaar medication price veripred generic cialis mifepristone and misoprostol in kenya buy cialis for daily use 2.5 mg procardia xl prices naproxen 550 mg is it good for knee pain 3 hexyne with lithium in liquid ammonia for sale can amoxicillin cause gas in infants vegas over the counter viagra how to order clonidine from canada metronidazole in saltwater tank elavil 10mg price avapro 300 mg discontinued eliza orlistat review doxycycline antibiotics for sale 150 mg ranitidine dosage for kids lasix wholesale flagyl in jamaica irbesartan 150 mg tabs and chords buy zithromax from asda pharmacy paroxetine ukulele lithium 7 number of neutrons in calcium drugs in pregnancy warfarin ingredients in prevacid medication guide duration of side effects of amoxicillin in dogs zyrtec d side effects drowsiness in spanish pessoas tetraplegicas que voltaren a andar in english 100 mg doxycycline lyme disease cialis address distributor in mauritius how much does generic cialis cost tridesilon generic propecia karsivan 100 mg dosierung ciprofloxacin is 100 mg too much prednisone for hives tritace 10 mg refundacja lisinopril 40 mg tablet lupin should i take benadryl in the morning has evista gone generic yet cialis in 48 ore plavix manufacturer canada nexium pill over the counter how many mg ibuprofen for 5 year old order viagra online singapore jobs how to get viagra illegally in south africa baclofen 20 mg erowid legal highs topamax available generic sklice generic lexapro mar metformin 500 mg lamisil cream safe is amoxicillin 875 mg chewable generic for augmentin 875 mg quetiapine hemifumarate drugbank united preparation h suppositories ingredients in aleve misoprostol dosage india irbesartan in heart failure is it safe to take panadol before drinking baclofen kaufen bosch dishwasher methotrexate shot cost cialis 20 mg ne ise yarar flutamide and leuprolide cost generic version levitra viagra paypal to states benicar 2 wheels self balancing scooter reviews losartan winthrop 50 mg comprar misoprostol copiapo azithromycin 100 mg5 ml susp generic atorvastatin europe prix logiciel flovent order gabapentin online uk history of socialism in venezuela warfarin monitoring guidelines uk weather lisinopril 10 mg side effects potaissm is it legal for me to buy nolvadex online in the uk allegra concept semsales olanzapine dose and cost clozapine 25 mg 2 x day what is naproxen 550 mg sodium daily terazosin generic names harga obat ramipril 5 mg is it safe to drink alcohol while taking allegra orlistat 120 mg usa buy acai juice toronto dapoxetine new in bangladesh voltaren 75 mg side effects kilawing kambing ingredients in aleve finasteride 1 mg canada valtrex mercadolibre costa vytorin uk losartan potassium 100 mg tab lup amoxicillin clavulanate potassium liquid dosage viagra price resource amoxicillin 1000 mg 3 times day order generic inderal reviews on dulcolax laxative clopidogrel actavis 75 mg haittavaikutukset 100 ug ml ampicillin drug warfarin dosing in elderly clomipramine sale generic for cialis 20mg how much does zyban cost purchase nexium dergboadre advani in aap ki adalat asaduddin lasix in pregnancy one dosage bactrim tabletas 80 mg. 400 mg ibuprofen chemists own voltaren actigo prix du online pharmacy, mastercard, viagra wellbutrin reviews drugs.com lovastatin monacolin k in statin labetalol 200 mg 3 times a day pill tricor pacific bankrupt does nyquil have ibuprofen in it furosemide 20 canada paroxetine 20 mg color montelukast sodium tab 10 mg taken with atarax para que se usa kamagra differences in solu mederol and decadron is tylenol with acetaminophen safe during pregnancy can u buy amoxicillin in spain propecia best results l thyroxine best time take cabine della costa allegra marketed formulations of losartan potassium nitroglycerin sr csps 9 mg. is claritin safe for 1 year old blumenkohl im baclofen grillen in deutschland bateau ms costa allegra bloodwurst ingredients in aleve contraindications for benadryl in asthma albuterol inhaler for sale without prescription seroquel 400 mg erowid vaults beta blockers propranolol headaches in pregnancy review nesina and metformin buy sildenafil citrate online in india cialis 20 mg sat?? fiyat? lansoprazole brand name in pakistani safe dose aspirin cats risperdal side effects in kids zithromax tablet 250 mg 500 mg how long before increase in effexor works kann man viagra apotheke rezeptfrei kaufen cialis euro visa skooma ingredients in benadryl motilium 10 mg pour femme enceinte sikandar e azam ingredients in aleve is topamax available as a generic progesterone level in luteal phase defect nicht in kraft tretinoin cream panadol cold and flu pe review buying xenical online south africa is sulfasalazine safe to take fluconazole 150mg tablets price india what does clomid do in women risperdal in the elderly simvastatin 10 mg efek samping body what does teva generic plavix look like voltaren 25 mg tablet obat untuk cheap flomax generic lithium ion vs lithium polymer safety list betamethasone generic names thuoc valparin 500mg to ml viagra here can i buy it .ca is there ibuprofen in naproxen corticosteroid iv to po conversion propranolol allopurinol zentiva 100 mg proscar in europe allegra pediatrico 6 ml lithium thionyl chloride batteries uk 12 mg seroquel is non drowsy claritin safe during pregnancy tadapox uk weather januvia cost uk visa buy piracetam flagyl cost in singapore splitting 5 mg finasteride lanzar or nexium over the counter can use creatine while accutane cost metformin 500 mg cm methotrexate dose in uveitis over the counter flagyl for dogs invirase generic plavix flagyl dosing in diverticulitis lowest cialis price canada benefits of metformin in pcos the cost of wellbutrin is it safe to take propranolol occasionally augmentin 200 mg pediatrico dosis clindamycin safe for breastfeeding how long has toprol xl been on the market apa hasiat obat dexamethasone 075 mg cost xeloda india ptld review article on aspirin buy antibiotics amoxicillin online uk toradol dosage in dogs can u take 20 mg singulair buy viagra over the counter in delhi motilium como usar skype 1255ay 150 mg wellbutrin posti da sogno in tretinoin manfaat diflucan fluconazole 50 mg 50 mg seroquel recreational premarin vaginal cream reviews cipro nord in inverno womens viagra uk naproxen 500 mg classification of organisms wal mart cost of levitra z propecia for sale diflucan 150 mg cijena ako nemas recept competitor brand of ofloxacin otic dosing benadryl mg kg metoprolol succ er 50 mg tab wikipedia ciprodex otic for sale fungsi dari dexamethasone salep levitra cheap pay with paypal does paxil come liquid kamagra oral jelly 100mg price strattera import united states side effects cartia xt 120 mg e drops nano ingredients in aleve toradol safe during breastfeeding singulair 10 mg preturi micardis 80 mg obat apa ya over nite delivery in usa on viagra flagyl competitors in pakistan plavix 75 mg classification of literature is glimepiride brand or generic posologie cialis 5 mg generic tacrolimus fda una sociedad civil puede realizar actos de comercio maxivision whole body ingredients in benadryl viagra price in nepal motorcycle allegra printing service in waterford michigan necesito receta medica para comprar orlistat french ondansetron papers in brit j anaesth 1997 prezzo sildenafil doc generici blood thinning foods naturally high in progesterone long safe take celebrex omeprazole generic walgreens nicotine lexapro market share price for neurontin 600 mg presentaciones omeprazole 20 mg how much is sertraline in philippines how does flomax work in kidney stones buy keflex without prescription lipitor generic equivalent name tamoxifen safe work practices information page does lexapro help with eating disorders buy acai berry pills ukulele never die lithium battery for sale metronidazole 2g onde comprar alfazema hydroxyurea in nigeria para que sirve terazosin 2 mg sotalol 160 mg bijsluiter medicijnen cefixime tablets 200 mg spcc karen pamelor generic bayer aspirin discovery paxil attorneys in california how many mg per kg of ibuprofen for infants ciprofloxacina 500 mg prospecto biotic pharma promethazine codeine syrup buy no prescription panadol in greece commissario europeo cipro tegretol cr 400 mg bijsluiter buscopan

The Communications Security Establishment:
Canada's Signals Intelligence Agency

Much of the text on these pages is drawn from Bill Robinson's article entitled, "Intelligence, Eavesdropping and Privacy: Who watches the Listeners?'' in The System: Crime and Punishment in Canadian Society: A Reader, Craig McKie, ed., Thompson Educational Publishers, Toronto, forthcoming.

Recent updates

What is the Communications Security Establishment?
Overview and Brief History
Policy, Operational and Administrative Control
Mandate
CSE/SRS Facilities
New Targets?
Recent Steps Toward Oversight

What is the Communications Security Establishment?

The Communications Security Establishment (CSE) is Canada's national Signals Intelligence (SIGINT) organization. SIGINT, as defined by the Canadian government, is "all processes involved in, and information and technical material derived from, the interception and study of foreign communications and non-communications electromagnetic emissions."[1] Subcategories include intelligence derived from communications, also known as Communications Intelligence (COMINT), intelligence derived from non-communications emissions such as radar, also known as Electronics Intelligence (ELINT), and intelligence derived from the telemetry transmissions of missiles or other equipment undergoing testing, also known as Telemetry Intelligence (TELINT). Note that SIGINT is restricted to foreign emissions under the Canadian government definition.

Strictly speaking, CSE is only part of Canada's SIGINT effort. A civilian agency of the Department of National Defence, CSE processes SIGINT, produces analyses, and disseminates reports to Canadian and allied consumer agencies. The actual collection of the SIGINT, however, is conducted by the Canadian Forces Supplementary Radio System (SRS), a component of the Canadian Armed Forces that operates under the direction of CSE.

CSE and the SRS in turn work in close co-operation with the giant American and British SIGINT agencies, the National Security Agency (NSA) and Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), Australia's Defence Signals Directorate (DSD), New Zealand's Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB), and a number of other SIGINT agencies in a global intelligence alliance known informally as the UKUSA community. CSE maintains permanent liaison officers at NSA HQ at Fort Meade, Maryland (CANSLO/W) and GCHQ in Cheltenham, UK (CANSLO/L). There are also NSA and GCHQ liaison officers at CSE HQ (SUSLO/O and BRLO, respectively). For more information about NSA, see the official NSA homepage or the much more informative Federation of American Scientists NSA homepage. For more information about GCHQ, see the IntelWeb GCHQ page.

Overview and Brief History

CSE began existence as the Communications Branch of the National Research Council (CBNRC). Authorized by Order-in-Council 54/3535, dated 13 April 1946, it was the direct descendent of Canada's wartime military and civilian SIGINT processing operations, which also had worked in close co-operation with their American and British counterparts.[2] Officially born on 1 September 1946, it began operations on 3 September 1946.

In 1947, CBNRC took on the additional responsibility of serving as the Canadian government's communications-electronic security (COMSEC) agency. Prior to 1947, the government's encryption systems and keys had been provided by the United Kingdom. ``This arrangement,'' the History of CBNRC noted dryly, ``did not guarantee the privacy of Canadian government classified communications.''[3] CSE continues to bear both SIGINT and COMSEC responsibilities today (the latter responsibility is now listed as the somewhat broader category Information Technology Security (INFOSEC)). For more about CSE's INFOSEC mandate and current INFOSEC activities, see the official CSE homepage.

On 1 April 1975, CBNRC was transferred from the National Research Council to the Department of National Defence and its name changed to the Communications Security Establishment. At the time of its transfer, CBNRC/CSE had about 590 personnel. A major buildup during the period 1981-1990 left CSE at its current strength of about 900.[4]

The following graph depicts CSE's employee strength from 1946-47 to 1993-94.

More information about CSE's employee strength and authorized establishment.

More about CSE's history.

The current Chief of CSE is A. Stewart Woolner. Under the Chief are five Directorates (Policy and Plans; SIGINT Production; Technology; INFOSEC; and Administration), each headed by a Director-General. Each Directorate, in turn, contains a number of Groups, each headed by a Director. An approximation of CSE's overall organization is depicted in this organization chart.

Information about CSE's Badge.

Supplementary Radio System

Canada's SIGINT collection (as opposed to processing) has always been conducted predominantly by military personnel. Small-scale SIGINT collection for the British Royal Navy began in 1925, but collection for Canadian processing began during the Second World War. All three services operated SIGINT collection facilities during the war, and all three continued to collect SIGINT after the war.

A unified collection organization, the Supplementary Radio System (SRS), was created in 1966 as part of the unification of the Canadian Armed Forces. The SRS remains responsible for the ``operation and maintenance of facilities dedicated to the signals intelligence collection role and high frequency radio direction-finding services.''[5]

As of the beginning of 1995, the strength of the SRS, counting civilian support staff at the SIGINT stations, was probably about 1250-1300; perhaps 900 of these were members of the Communicator Research (291) trade, i.e., the actual intercept operators.

Policy, Operational and Administrative Control

Control over Canadian SIGINT activities is divided, with policy and operational control exercised by Cabinet and the Privy Council Office, and administrative control exercised by the Minister and Deputy Minister of National Defence: ``The Chief of CSE is accountable to the Deputy Minister of National Defence for financial and administrative matters, and to the Deputy Clerk (Security and Intelligence, and Counsel) in the PCO for policy and operational matters.''[6]

In practice, policy and operational control is exercised by the Deputy Clerk (Security and Intelligence, and Counsel) and the Intelligence Advisory Committee, both of the Privy Council Office, working under the direction of the Interdepartmental Committee on Security and Intelligence (ICSI) and, ultimately, the Cabinet Committee on Security and Intelligence (CCSI). ``The ICSI maintains general policy control over all aspects of the collection, processing and dissemination of SIGINT and exercises this control through the Intelligence Advisory Committee (IAC) for national SIGINT, and the Canadian Forces for tactical COMINT and ELINT.''[7] The Chief of CSE is an associate member of the ICSI.[8]

Among its other duties, the IAC ``co-ordinates the Canadian SIGINT program with other national intelligence activities and formulates guidance, requirements and priorities for the provision of SIGINT product.''[9] (Some user requirements are also provided to CSE bilaterally by SIGINT customer departments.)

Administrative control is exercised by the Minister and Deputy Minister of the Department of National Defence. ``The Minister approves CSE's major capital expenditures, its annual Multi-Year Operation Plan, and (with CCSI) major CSE initiatives with significant policy or legal implications.''[10]

The Minister of National Defence is the member of Cabinet accountable to Parliament for CSE.[11] It is the responsibility of the Deputy Clerk (Security and Intelligence, and Counsel), ``in co-operation with the deputy minister of National Defence, to ensure the Minister of National Defence [is] knowledgeable about matters of CSE, and able to respond to any questions that would be put on that subject.''[12] In practice, however, it is likely that few ministers of National Defence ever obtain a detailed knowledge of the nature and activities of CSE. Former Minister of National Defence Jean-Jacques Blais has stated, for example, that ``my knowledge of the Communications Security Establishment was very superficial indeed when I was minister of defence.''[13]

Control over INFOSEC activities is organized similarly, except that it is exercised through the Security Advisory Committee of the PCO instead of the Intelligence Advisory Committee.

Mandate

The formal mandate of CSE is a classified document, presumably approved by the Cabinet Committee on Security and Intelligence; it has never been laid out in statute. As demonstrated above, however, the general nature of CSE's mandate is not secret. IAC SIGINT Memorandum No. 1 confirms that ``the Communications Security Establishment (CSE) of the Department of National Defence has been established as the Canadian National SIGINT Centre, and has been given the responsibility for providing SIGINT to meet the needs of the Federal Government.''[14] What remains secret is the extent to which the communications of Canadians are considered to fall within the SIGINT needs of the Canadian government.

The Canadian public has been told on a number of occasions that CSE's formal mandate restricts it to the collection of ``foreign intelligence''.[15] The government's definition of SIGINT, quoted at the beginning of this chapter, would appear to confirm this assurance.

It is almost certainly significant, however, that the government definition of ``foreign'' communications has never been made public; it was deleted in its entirety from the released version of IAC SIGINT Memorandum No. 1. Depending on the precise definition that the government uses, such communications might include:

There is reason to believe that the government's definition does include at least some of these meanings. For example, then-Solicitor General Robert Kaplan stated explicitly in his 1984 testimony that CSE could, under certain circumstances, ``intercept signals that begin and end in Canada, that begin in Canada and end abroad or the reverse.''[16]

It would appear, therefore, that CSE's ``foreign intelligence'' mandate does permit it to intercept many types of communications that do involve Canadian participants. In fact, the Department of National Defence has admitted that CSE occasionally intercepts communications that involve or contain information about Canadians: ``CSE targets only foreign communications, which, on rare occasions, contain personal information about Canadian citizens and landed immigrants.''[17] In addition, the government has confirmed that CSE maintains a data bank, DND/P-PU-040, ``Security and Intelligence Information Files,'' that contains ``information concerning [Canadians] identified as potential risks to national security.''[18] Nevertheless, the issue of how often and how systematically CSE can and does intercept the communications of Canadians remains unresolved. More on CSE and Canadian communications.

CSE/SRS Facilities

See also the complete list of postwar Canadian SIGINT sites.

New Targets?

The end of the Cold War and dissolution of the Soviet Union have made CSE's Soviet military targets less important than they once were. As a result, CSE almost certainly is under pressure either to shrink or to find new targets. Some shrinkage is likely to take place, but DND's plans for the SRS suggest that new targets are also on the CSE/SRS agenda. In 1994, DND decided to reduce the size of the SRS support staff by converting the facilities at Alert, Gander, and Masset to remote operations by 1997-98. But the number of SRS intercept operators is likely to shrink by only 10-15 per cent as a result of this initiative. The remaining personnel will be redeployed to Ottawa and/or Leitrim, where some will continue work related to the Alert, Gander, and Masset sites, and others (presumably) will be assigned to new targets.

For obvious reasons, the identity of these new targets has not been revealed. It is almost certain, however, that they are located among the growing volume of civilian traffic carried by satellite. The communications satellites that serve Latin America are more likely to be the targets of this expansion than Canadian satellites are, but any step towards the more systematic monitoring of civilian communications should be of concern. Who will be targeted next?

Recent Steps Toward Oversight

Unlike CSIS, which has the SIRC, CSE has never had any form of independent oversight organization to ensure that its invasive powers are not abused. In recent years, the establishment of an independent oversight committee has been recommended both by the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act and by the SIRC itself.[19] The response of the Mulroney government was that ``a broad accountability system for CSE is in place.''[20] This ``system,'' however, was no more than CSE's normal relationship with the officials at ICSI and DND who have responsibility for the SIGINT program. As the record of the RCMP Security Service, and later CSIS, demonstrated, intelligence agencies cannot be relied upon to police themselves.[21]

The Chretien government initially also maintained that CSE did not require independent oversight. To its credit, however, on 21 March 1995 it permitted the passage of a motion by MP Derek Lee calling on the government to ``establish an independent external mechanism to review the operations of the Communications Security Establishment, CSE, similar to the role played by the Security Intelligence Review Committee for the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, and table a report annually in the House.''[22] The following day, Defence Minister David Collenette announced that the government would indeed establish such a mechanism. He did not, however, provide any details of the government's plans, stating only that, ``in principle, the government supports an oversight mechanism for the CSE.''[23]

The above analysis suggests that a truly effective oversight mechanism would require:

A number of other reforms also would be useful, including: It remains to be seen whether the oversight mechanism to be established will be designed to oversee Canadian SIGINT activities or to overlook their use against Canadians. The government's record in fulfilling the above requirements should provide the answer to that question.

Endnotes

[1] Kevin O'Neill, ed., History of CBNRC, 1987, Chapter 2, Annex G (IAC SIGINT Memorandum No. 1, CONTROL OF SIGNAL INTELLIGENCE (SIGINT) IN CANADA, 24 August 1977), released in severed form under the Access to Information Act.

[2] For more information on Canada's wartime SIGINT activities, see John Bryden, Best-Kept Secret: Canadian Secret Intelligence in the Second World War, Lester Publishing, 1993.

[3] History of CBNRC, Chapter 17, p. 2.

[4] Ward Elcock, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Sub-Committee on National Security, 15 June 1993, p. 11:9; Statement by Margaret Bloodworth, Deputy Clerk, Security and Intelligence, to Standing Committee on National Defence and Veterans Affairs, 2 May 1995.

[5] Defence 90, Supply and Services, 1991, p. 48.

[6] On Course: National Security for the 1990s, Solicitor General, 1991, p. 54.

[7] History of CBNRC, Chapter 2, Annex G.

[8] Ward Elcock, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act, 24 April 1990, p. 27:9.

[9] History of CBNRC, Chapter 2, Annex G.

[10] On Course, p. 54.

[11] On Course, p. 54.

[12] Blair Seaborn, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act, 20 February 1990, p. 16:9.

[13] Quoted in Peter Moon, ``Spy agency left minister in dark,'' Globe and Mail, 3 June 1991, p. A4. Elsewhere Blais has commented that ``While I had responsibility for the estimates presented to Parliament, that responsibility did not extend to the exercise of ministerial control over the CSE. In practice the control was bureaucratic, in my view short-circuiting the principle of political accountability on which our democracy is founded.'' (Jean Jacques Blais, ``Committee should be expanded to review other agencies,'' Ottawa Citizen, 2 July 1992, p. A11.)

[14] History of CBNRC, Chapter 2, Annex G

[15] See, e.g., Minister of State (External Relations) Jean-Luc Pepin, testimony, Proceedings of the Special Committee of the Senate on the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, 22 September 1983, p. 19.

[16] Robert Kaplan, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Standing Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs, 5 April 1984, p. 11:68.

[17] Letter from Commander F.B. Frewer, Director Public Affairs Operations, National Defence, to Peter Moon, 15 April 1991.

[18] Personal Information Index 1988, 1988, p. 47- 3.

[19] In Flux But Not in Crisis, report of the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act, September 1990, pp. 152-3; Annual Report 1988-89, Security Intelligence Review Committee, 1989.

[20] On Course, p. 55.

[21] There is little reason to expect that CSE has been any more reliable in this respect. See, for example, the allegations in the book Spyworld (Mike Frost and Michel Gratton, Spyworld: Inside the Canadian and American Intelligence Establishments, Doubleday Canada, 1994) concerning the interception of Quebec government communications. In 1991, ``former CSE employees and other sources,'' told the Globe and Mail that ``in the past the agency routinely broke Canadian laws in the collection of intelligence involving Canadians.'' (Peter Moon, ``Secrecy shrouds spy agency,'' Globe and Mail, 27 May 1991, pp. A1, A4.) This allegation has not been proven, but a disquieting example of CSE failing to follow appropriate procedures and respect the rights of one of its own employees is on the public record in Muriel Korngold Wexler, Record of Decision (file 166-13-17850), Public Service Staff Relations Board, 12 March 1990. This document includes a detailed description of the mistreatment and eventual unjust firing of CSE cryptanalyst Edwina Slattery during the 1980s. It should be noted that Ms. Slattery considers the Record of Decision's description of the events surrounding her firing to be inaccurate in many respects, notwithstanding the fact that it supported her claim that she had been unjustly fired and recommended that she receive compensation equivalent to two years' pay. Ms. Slattery continues to pursue the case in the Federal Court of Canada.

[22] House of Commons Debates, 21 March 1995, pp. 10815-10820.

[23] Tu Thanh Ha, ``Secretive agency to be more open, Collenette says,'' Globe and Mail, 23 March 1995, p. A5.

Advanced TSCM Signals Detection and Analysis
TSCM - Sweeping the Spectrum for Eavesdropping Devices

Any comments or questions regarding this specific page?

Please feel free to sign our Guest Book

Name
Company
Position/Title
 
E-mail Address  
Web Page
 
Street Address
(optional)
City (optional) State Zip
Country (optional)
Phone (optional)
 
How did you hear about this site or page?
Do you need to have a bug sweep or other TSCM service performed?
Do you need any TSCM equipment?
 
Comments



| Home | What is TSCM | Types of Bugs | Warning Signs You're Bugged |
| How To Behave if Bugged | TSCM Threat Levels | How To Engage a TSCM Firm |
| Qualifications | TSCM Protocol | Bug Frequencies | Phone Taps and Bugging |
| Signal Analysis | TDR Analysis | TDR Tutorial | Wiretapping | Training | Tools |
| Equipment | OSC-5000 | Kaiser | Riser Bond | Avcom | Search Rcvrs |
| Outside Links | Recommended TSCM Books | TSCM Reference Library |
| Recommended U.S. TSCM Firms | TSCM-L Mailing List |


-----------------------

    To be contacted for a confidential consultation
    please E-mail: jmatk@tscm.com

    or send a letter via US Mail to:
    James M. Atkinson
    Granite Island Group
    127 Eastern Avenue #291
    Gloucester, MA 01931-8008

    or call:
    Telephone: (978) 546-3803 / Fax: (978) 546-9467

    URL: http://www.tscm.com/

Copyright ©2002, Granite Island Group