metformin insulin tablet price in india colcrys 0.6 mg tab ar discontinuation of risperidone in alzheimer disease labetalol 100 mg embarazo mobic pill price bystolic nebivolol 5 mg can i cut prometrium in half coumadin in bioprosthetic valves acyclovir prices walmart price ondansetron hcl cost of brand name wellbutrin sr price reductin for lexapro does sumatriptan have tylenol in it what is modeofaction in clopidogrel bisulfate took 2 cialis 5 mg by accident minocycline generics asventol montelukast 10 mg costo traino costa allegra lexapro 20 mg and weight loss ingredients in gabapentin 300mg how many pills in viagra pack cdiscount viagra much does dulcolax laxative cost how long does it take for effexor to get in your system buy cialis ho chi minh singulair use in copd what does atenolol cost amoxicillin price walmart griseofulvin ultra 250 mg coupon cost of neurontin vs lyrica prednisone without prescriptions canada really viagra cut prilosec pill in half acyclovir cream cost at cvs is strattera 40 mg like adderall is clotrimazole 1 safe during pregnancy methocarbamol 750 mg tablet price safe pregnant women take zantac over the counter protonix substitute furosemide medication generic gabapentin 300 mg and tramadol 50 mg brazil clopidogrel price levonorgestrel etinilestradiol 0.15 mg lincocin tabletas 500 mg wo bestellt man viagra generic viagra online fast shipping to usa citalopram in kids metoprolol 25 mg enciclopedia plavix ringing in ears jock itch fluconazole dosage 150 mg amitriptyline in trigeminal neuralgia prednisone over counter dogs cephalexin oral capsule 500 mg side effects orlistat 120mg price review if you take 40 mg of cialis warfarin therapeutic range uk where can i buy xenical in toronto canada 50 mg clomid no ovulation plavix 75 mg preço acquistare cialis online italia estradiol valerate injection online where can i buy motrin for infants pa bar reciprocal states clindamycin gel price in india is ondansetron odt 4 mg good for a 7 year old imitrex price canada is it safe to take 50 mg of celexa panadol and nurofen in babies claritin d price at walgreens augmentin 400 mg dosaggio what is the best cialis or viagra 80 mg simvastatin rhabdomyolysis propranolol para se usa amoxicillin clavulanate potassium 875 mg alcohol venlafaxine 50 mg tab levitra price in walgrens taking fluconazole 2 times in one week escitalopram in usa viagra sales no prescription is zyprexa safe for dogs levitra polen kaufen azithromycin medicine india ciprodex otic is on walmart plan recherche prix du viagra can i buy cialis in walmart topamax migraine reviews what are the side effects of topiramate 50 mg cialis price strategy buy 1 gram of zithromax is there bactrim in the uk methotrexate how long does it stay in system does hydroxyzine show up in drug tests actove ingredient in viagra micardis 40 mg coupon risek omeprazole 20 mg side effects of omeprazole 10 mg where to buy fish amoxicillin best place for online viagra getting cialis across the border from mexico visiter le costa allegra flagyl for vomiting in dogs side effects of depakote in dementia patients ibuprofen overdose symptoms in adults isotretinoina anvisa does prednisone in dogs make them tired warfarin in palliative care clindamycin 600 mg wikipedia amoxicillin in diabetes claritin product monograph canada ciloxan fülcsepp 5 ml antibiotics online azithromycin viagra tablets price uae price for gabapentin at walmart cymbalta 60 mg faydalar? what is the best time of day to take glimepiride where to buy premarin online cheapest viagra for sale uk cialis generic cilpa pain specialists in stockton ca cara pemakaian salep mata oxytetracycline cialis 10 mg vaikutusaika abilify post traumatic stress disorder cialis for sale paypal what is in doxepin naltrexone sales ampicillin 500 mg po voltaren sr 75 mg ne icin kullanilir ibuprofen 600 mg rugpijn ondansetron 4 mg information is paxil safe for anxiety good cheap viagra difference in cialis mg tadacip whartisthebestin reviews floxing research tec pp in neoplasia wayne a schroder best site buy nolvadex price of lamictal without insurance how much is hydroxyzine at walmart ingredients in prednisone generic lisinopril for sale topamax overnight delivery viagra replacement uk discount coupon for naprelan meloxicam 15 mg side effects espanol no viagra abilify reactive attachment disorder safe take acyclovir while nursing sintomas cytotec pode causar ritemed metformin hcl 500 mg buy colofac ibs dominos pizza dublin artane buy synthroid with no prescription ofloxacin 5 ml generic cialis gelcap como usar o remedio cytotec para aborto valsartan 80 mg absetzen tamoxifeno 200 mg trileptal 300 mg effets secondaires precio seroquel 300 mg ofloxacin solubility in ethanol ivermectin purchase online doxepin 25 mg information remeron 30 mg ek?i sözlük cefuroxime 250 mg suspension over counter equivalent to nexium cialis 20mg price in canada what is name of plavix in pakistan how long does topamax stay in system acyclovir 400 mg tab price ranitidine 150 mg prescription buy propranolol online how long does a prednisone stay in the body lasix and albumin in anasarca zovirax tablets in dublin viagra in australia next day over counter viagra walmart cephalexin 500 mg capsule for tooth infection artane dublin postal code where can i buy 3 g amoxil sachets nizoral tab 200 mg norvasc usage cleocin ovuli in gravidanza buying plavix online from ireland atorvastatin calcium 10 mg oral tablet ibuprofen how much in 24 hours propranolol 60 mg sa how does metformin work in type 2 diabetes taking 30 mg of celexa albuterol 3 mg kg escitalopram in albania generic viagra masti 100 forum buy synthroid online no prescription reviews of depo provera shots reviews mobicool t35 is it safe to stop metoprolol cialis shop uk reviews for hydroxyzine viagra pode causar priapismo side effects of cialis once a day in men does clomid work in women over 40 nitroglycerin how much does an iv price pharmacie canada viagra toronto prozac pain in throat call center in kamagra jelly buyers which states have reciprocity for teachers are cialis soft tabs safe how to buy viagra from canada cheap cialis 5mg 20 mg liquid clomid buy has cymbalta go generic escitalopram 15mg order cialis brand professional generic difference companies that make orlistat in europe metronidazole injection usp 500 mg red viagra information benefit in urdu amlodipine besylate 5mg tablets in india meloxicam 15 mg doses generic levitra canada 40 mg monopril authorized generic carbamazepine in pregnancy and lactation effexor lawsuit uk online viagra kaufen rezeptfrei sams club generic lipitor tenormin alternate brands metoprolol 50 mg preis is benadryl safe for a one year old dulcolax tablets mg is zantac 75 safe during first trimester taking cialis 20 mg everyday bupropion price increase allegra ou desalex carry permit pa reciprocal states buy seroquel 50 mg clonidine catapres 0.2 mg will effexor show up in a drug test voltaren over the counter canada amlodipine generics names use misoprostol 100 mg buy clomiphene rsa pharmacies without prescription generic albuterol hfa nexium 20 mg efectos espanol ofloxacin 200 mg preis side effects of metronidazole in dogs rashes inactive ingredients in voltaren voltaren 75 mg a narcotic reciprocal inhibition papers latency in behav brain sci can you get an online prescription for viagra cost generic depo provera zithromax z pak cost walgreens plavix 12.5 mg que es orlistat 60 mg para que sirve el medicamento provera 5 mg costco fexofenadine 180 mg permethrin buy online how much does wellbutrin cost in ireland allegra kadet united states zithromax at walmart cost of tamoxifen in ireland nitrofurantoin 100 mg pille take liquid tadalafil allegra mcevedy sausage kale online viagra with cfash delivery date of lok adalat in delhi is sildenafil from india safe doxycycline monohydrate 100 mg pregnancy cost of 300 mg seroquel doctors for viagra in rochester ny is augmentin safe for diabetics can buy cymbalta hctz 12.5 lisinopril 10 mg side effects venlafaxine generic for cymbalta nombre generico prilosec prevacid buy online generic pill for celebrex zovirax cream walmart price side effects from omeprazole in infants sildenafil citrate 100mg reviews diltiazem inwood 240 mg sa cap how long prednisone a dog needs in thrombocytopenia cost of viagra in pune how much is viagra uk cost of omeprazole otc how much codeine in promethazine codeine syrup where can i buy cialis in melbourne 50 mg ml ampicillin can you buy viagra in america side effects of clomid in males cheap plavix 75 mg zyprexa 10 mg film tablet singulair 4 mg sobredosis prednisolone acetate drops prices cost of viagra in malaysia esomeprazole available generically cialis buy in london who makes generic strattera doxycycline hyclate 100mg tab price mobic 15 mg medicament amoxicillin dosing in pregnancy shelf life of cipro 250 mg tab warfarin trade name in pak zithromax online in us naproxen maximum safe dosage cialis cost 10 vs 20 mg ciproxin 1000 generico ho comprato viagra online generico do atacand 8 mg much generic cymbalta online generic viagra without prescription viagra bestellen pfizer often take claritin 10 mg cold sore zovirax reviews metformin teva usa metformin major cheap lisinopril genuine viagra uk cheapest bijwerkingen telmisartan 40 mg effects of accutane in men domperidone gerd in babies does metronidazole really work para que sirve prozac 10 mg meloxicam 7 5 mg pre switching tylenol and ibuprofen in infants pravachol in india generic cialis c 80 singulair global sales what can i use in place of nexium crestor tabletas 10 mg lozol hereisthebestin no prescription ok to cut lisinopril in half revista de indias articles tâmis peixoto parron dapoxetine 30mg price renova spa cabo reviews bula finasteride 1 mg prevacid dosage over the counter solubility of tamoxifen in ethanol nombre generico y comercial de cytotec motilium m 10 mg ????? buying brand viagra online norvasc 10 mg tablete when will singulair be available as a generic dosage of sildenafil in erectile dysfunction many ml bottle amoxicillin plavix in stroke patients cialis where to buy malaysia amoxil 500 online wo kann ich sicher kamagra kaufen metformin 500mg not absorbing in body how much vitamin d is in fosamax d taking prednisone at bedtime which mg cheap forzest rowcmoadreders nimodipine in sah dose buy meloxicam with no prescription purchase zyloprim rowcmoadreders paxil category in pregnancy sildenafil hennig online amlodipine a review of analytical methods misoprostol systematic review can you buy viagra in nassau bahama tacrolimus api manufacturer in india prednisone 50 mg and alcohol does voltaren 75 mg tab have ibuprofen in them pantoprazole first thing in the morning is it safe to take wellbutrin and ritalin benadryl 50 mg for dogs zantac 50 mg can buy cialis line which ppi is safe to use with plavix how much is 5mg cialis cost with insurance paxil 20 mg endikasyon contraindicaciones crestor 20 mg prednisone 20 mg ear infection dexamethasone 0 75 mg adalah adalat cap. 10 mg acquista online cialis sicuro gabapentin 300 mg for shingles nerve pain prozac and protein in urine can i take cialis 10 mg daily toprol xl generic availability is metronidazole good in pregnancy cvs drug prices for cialis 2.5mg cataflam pediatrico 12.5 mg amoxicillin 500 mg 3 times day 5 days herb viagra wholesale looking for viagra in houston buy celebrex overnight lasix and weight loss in dogs voltaren schmerzgel in der schwangerschaft generic version proventil different brands panadol zyrtec vs. claritin in toddlers safety of colchicine therapy during pregnancy diflucan 150 uk bupropion hcl 100 mg tablettev quanto costa il viagra che si scioglie in bocca how long should i take amoxicillin 500 mg 50 mg clomid ovulation motrin suspension infantil 20 mg when is the best time to get the depo provera shot subscribe by email in viagra online private prescription finasteride 1mg atenolol 50 mg contraindicaciones pastillas celebrex 200 mg where can i buy viagra pills in vancouver cephalexin dose in adults panadol osteo 650 mg dapoxatina si sildenafil sitrat europe pharmacy buy maxolon tablets azithromycin 250 mg treatment pregnancy celebrex settlement canada prevacid safe take while nursing 1000 mg naproxen sodium what is socialist party usa phone number paroxetine 10 mg prijs how does colchicine work in pericarditis reviews for prozac nation film sildenafil 25 mg para que sirve is neurontin a controlled substance in tennessee will lisinopril show up in a drug test for the military astelin generic equivalent generic estrace cream from canada how much is viagra in wallgreens online levitra in canada cialis daily in canada amoxicillin liquid for sale for kids can premarin 0.3 mg cause weight gain dose fluconazole work for thursh in the mouth is there a generic for zithromax flagyl 400 mg ingredients where to get cialis in malaysia zyrtec available over counter ivermectin in kittens what are the side effects of generic fosamax is it safe to combine cocaine and viagra viagra overnight delivery duration of action of metformin 500 mg cytotec comprar en cali amlodipine side effects in humans propecia generics uk trazodone uk shortage trazodone side effects in mouth omeprazole 20 mg delayed release tablets is cephalexin safe for people zantac is safe in pregnancy which is the best kamagra 50 or 100mg aldactone use in chf augmentin is there a generic cuanto cuesta arava 20 mg buy nexium online ireland generic name for amlodipine dosage for zithromax in cats depakote in mexico 25 mg prednisone high dose dom clarithromycin 500 mg cialis 20 mg y spray doxycycline tablets price in canada grifulvin hereisthebestin online se puede tomar alcohol con voltaren retard 75 mg can i take 150 mg of viagra daily meijer gabapentin 600mg cost zyvoxid price average cost generic cialis cheapest paypal viagra 150 ml ibuprofen safe citalopram is there caffeine in tylenol 2 how long does 800mg of ibuprofen stay in your system cialis 5 mg yeterli notice motilium 1mg ml specialist doctors in glen burnie buy diflucan capsules online no prescription viagra home office in toronto phenergan use labor delivery what is cephalexin capsules 500 mg used for viagra online authentic where to buy metformin norvasc 10 mg side effects on kidneys benicar 40 mg 12.5 kamagra legal australia difference between retin a and generic tretinoin can benadryl cause anemia in dogs zantac shortage australia actos procesales en argentina como usar cataflam gel ibuprofen 400 mg extra strength does olanzapine show up in a 10 panel drug test where can i buy allegra in canada hiw long does 10 mg cialis last what is the street value of strattera 40 mg buy prednisone for cats no prescription uk name brands for ketoconazole cream gabapentin 1200 mg dose prozac 60 mg daily generic how long does 1000 mg of zithromax stay in your system ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab side effects atenolol 25 mg tablet zyd can i get cialis online cilostazol generico chile how to buy viagra from pfizer where to get viagra in london orlistat ratiopharm 60 mg preisvergleich citalopram hbr 40 mg give you the same high as adderall rizatriptan brand name india took 350 mg benadryl cost of levitra at walmart pharmacy

The Communications Security Establishment:
Canada's Signals Intelligence Agency

Much of the text on these pages is drawn from Bill Robinson's article entitled, "Intelligence, Eavesdropping and Privacy: Who watches the Listeners?'' in The System: Crime and Punishment in Canadian Society: A Reader, Craig McKie, ed., Thompson Educational Publishers, Toronto, forthcoming.

Recent updates

What is the Communications Security Establishment?
Overview and Brief History
Policy, Operational and Administrative Control
Mandate
CSE/SRS Facilities
New Targets?
Recent Steps Toward Oversight

What is the Communications Security Establishment?

The Communications Security Establishment (CSE) is Canada's national Signals Intelligence (SIGINT) organization. SIGINT, as defined by the Canadian government, is "all processes involved in, and information and technical material derived from, the interception and study of foreign communications and non-communications electromagnetic emissions."[1] Subcategories include intelligence derived from communications, also known as Communications Intelligence (COMINT), intelligence derived from non-communications emissions such as radar, also known as Electronics Intelligence (ELINT), and intelligence derived from the telemetry transmissions of missiles or other equipment undergoing testing, also known as Telemetry Intelligence (TELINT). Note that SIGINT is restricted to foreign emissions under the Canadian government definition.

Strictly speaking, CSE is only part of Canada's SIGINT effort. A civilian agency of the Department of National Defence, CSE processes SIGINT, produces analyses, and disseminates reports to Canadian and allied consumer agencies. The actual collection of the SIGINT, however, is conducted by the Canadian Forces Supplementary Radio System (SRS), a component of the Canadian Armed Forces that operates under the direction of CSE.

CSE and the SRS in turn work in close co-operation with the giant American and British SIGINT agencies, the National Security Agency (NSA) and Government Communications Headquarters (GCHQ), Australia's Defence Signals Directorate (DSD), New Zealand's Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB), and a number of other SIGINT agencies in a global intelligence alliance known informally as the UKUSA community. CSE maintains permanent liaison officers at NSA HQ at Fort Meade, Maryland (CANSLO/W) and GCHQ in Cheltenham, UK (CANSLO/L). There are also NSA and GCHQ liaison officers at CSE HQ (SUSLO/O and BRLO, respectively). For more information about NSA, see the official NSA homepage or the much more informative Federation of American Scientists NSA homepage. For more information about GCHQ, see the IntelWeb GCHQ page.

Overview and Brief History

CSE began existence as the Communications Branch of the National Research Council (CBNRC). Authorized by Order-in-Council 54/3535, dated 13 April 1946, it was the direct descendent of Canada's wartime military and civilian SIGINT processing operations, which also had worked in close co-operation with their American and British counterparts.[2] Officially born on 1 September 1946, it began operations on 3 September 1946.

In 1947, CBNRC took on the additional responsibility of serving as the Canadian government's communications-electronic security (COMSEC) agency. Prior to 1947, the government's encryption systems and keys had been provided by the United Kingdom. ``This arrangement,'' the History of CBNRC noted dryly, ``did not guarantee the privacy of Canadian government classified communications.''[3] CSE continues to bear both SIGINT and COMSEC responsibilities today (the latter responsibility is now listed as the somewhat broader category Information Technology Security (INFOSEC)). For more about CSE's INFOSEC mandate and current INFOSEC activities, see the official CSE homepage.

On 1 April 1975, CBNRC was transferred from the National Research Council to the Department of National Defence and its name changed to the Communications Security Establishment. At the time of its transfer, CBNRC/CSE had about 590 personnel. A major buildup during the period 1981-1990 left CSE at its current strength of about 900.[4]

The following graph depicts CSE's employee strength from 1946-47 to 1993-94.

More information about CSE's employee strength and authorized establishment.

More about CSE's history.

The current Chief of CSE is A. Stewart Woolner. Under the Chief are five Directorates (Policy and Plans; SIGINT Production; Technology; INFOSEC; and Administration), each headed by a Director-General. Each Directorate, in turn, contains a number of Groups, each headed by a Director. An approximation of CSE's overall organization is depicted in this organization chart.

Information about CSE's Badge.

Supplementary Radio System

Canada's SIGINT collection (as opposed to processing) has always been conducted predominantly by military personnel. Small-scale SIGINT collection for the British Royal Navy began in 1925, but collection for Canadian processing began during the Second World War. All three services operated SIGINT collection facilities during the war, and all three continued to collect SIGINT after the war.

A unified collection organization, the Supplementary Radio System (SRS), was created in 1966 as part of the unification of the Canadian Armed Forces. The SRS remains responsible for the ``operation and maintenance of facilities dedicated to the signals intelligence collection role and high frequency radio direction-finding services.''[5]

As of the beginning of 1995, the strength of the SRS, counting civilian support staff at the SIGINT stations, was probably about 1250-1300; perhaps 900 of these were members of the Communicator Research (291) trade, i.e., the actual intercept operators.

Policy, Operational and Administrative Control

Control over Canadian SIGINT activities is divided, with policy and operational control exercised by Cabinet and the Privy Council Office, and administrative control exercised by the Minister and Deputy Minister of National Defence: ``The Chief of CSE is accountable to the Deputy Minister of National Defence for financial and administrative matters, and to the Deputy Clerk (Security and Intelligence, and Counsel) in the PCO for policy and operational matters.''[6]

In practice, policy and operational control is exercised by the Deputy Clerk (Security and Intelligence, and Counsel) and the Intelligence Advisory Committee, both of the Privy Council Office, working under the direction of the Interdepartmental Committee on Security and Intelligence (ICSI) and, ultimately, the Cabinet Committee on Security and Intelligence (CCSI). ``The ICSI maintains general policy control over all aspects of the collection, processing and dissemination of SIGINT and exercises this control through the Intelligence Advisory Committee (IAC) for national SIGINT, and the Canadian Forces for tactical COMINT and ELINT.''[7] The Chief of CSE is an associate member of the ICSI.[8]

Among its other duties, the IAC ``co-ordinates the Canadian SIGINT program with other national intelligence activities and formulates guidance, requirements and priorities for the provision of SIGINT product.''[9] (Some user requirements are also provided to CSE bilaterally by SIGINT customer departments.)

Administrative control is exercised by the Minister and Deputy Minister of the Department of National Defence. ``The Minister approves CSE's major capital expenditures, its annual Multi-Year Operation Plan, and (with CCSI) major CSE initiatives with significant policy or legal implications.''[10]

The Minister of National Defence is the member of Cabinet accountable to Parliament for CSE.[11] It is the responsibility of the Deputy Clerk (Security and Intelligence, and Counsel), ``in co-operation with the deputy minister of National Defence, to ensure the Minister of National Defence [is] knowledgeable about matters of CSE, and able to respond to any questions that would be put on that subject.''[12] In practice, however, it is likely that few ministers of National Defence ever obtain a detailed knowledge of the nature and activities of CSE. Former Minister of National Defence Jean-Jacques Blais has stated, for example, that ``my knowledge of the Communications Security Establishment was very superficial indeed when I was minister of defence.''[13]

Control over INFOSEC activities is organized similarly, except that it is exercised through the Security Advisory Committee of the PCO instead of the Intelligence Advisory Committee.

Mandate

The formal mandate of CSE is a classified document, presumably approved by the Cabinet Committee on Security and Intelligence; it has never been laid out in statute. As demonstrated above, however, the general nature of CSE's mandate is not secret. IAC SIGINT Memorandum No. 1 confirms that ``the Communications Security Establishment (CSE) of the Department of National Defence has been established as the Canadian National SIGINT Centre, and has been given the responsibility for providing SIGINT to meet the needs of the Federal Government.''[14] What remains secret is the extent to which the communications of Canadians are considered to fall within the SIGINT needs of the Canadian government.

The Canadian public has been told on a number of occasions that CSE's formal mandate restricts it to the collection of ``foreign intelligence''.[15] The government's definition of SIGINT, quoted at the beginning of this chapter, would appear to confirm this assurance.

It is almost certainly significant, however, that the government definition of ``foreign'' communications has never been made public; it was deleted in its entirety from the released version of IAC SIGINT Memorandum No. 1. Depending on the precise definition that the government uses, such communications might include:

There is reason to believe that the government's definition does include at least some of these meanings. For example, then-Solicitor General Robert Kaplan stated explicitly in his 1984 testimony that CSE could, under certain circumstances, ``intercept signals that begin and end in Canada, that begin in Canada and end abroad or the reverse.''[16]

It would appear, therefore, that CSE's ``foreign intelligence'' mandate does permit it to intercept many types of communications that do involve Canadian participants. In fact, the Department of National Defence has admitted that CSE occasionally intercepts communications that involve or contain information about Canadians: ``CSE targets only foreign communications, which, on rare occasions, contain personal information about Canadian citizens and landed immigrants.''[17] In addition, the government has confirmed that CSE maintains a data bank, DND/P-PU-040, ``Security and Intelligence Information Files,'' that contains ``information concerning [Canadians] identified as potential risks to national security.''[18] Nevertheless, the issue of how often and how systematically CSE can and does intercept the communications of Canadians remains unresolved. More on CSE and Canadian communications.

CSE/SRS Facilities

See also the complete list of postwar Canadian SIGINT sites.

New Targets?

The end of the Cold War and dissolution of the Soviet Union have made CSE's Soviet military targets less important than they once were. As a result, CSE almost certainly is under pressure either to shrink or to find new targets. Some shrinkage is likely to take place, but DND's plans for the SRS suggest that new targets are also on the CSE/SRS agenda. In 1994, DND decided to reduce the size of the SRS support staff by converting the facilities at Alert, Gander, and Masset to remote operations by 1997-98. But the number of SRS intercept operators is likely to shrink by only 10-15 per cent as a result of this initiative. The remaining personnel will be redeployed to Ottawa and/or Leitrim, where some will continue work related to the Alert, Gander, and Masset sites, and others (presumably) will be assigned to new targets.

For obvious reasons, the identity of these new targets has not been revealed. It is almost certain, however, that they are located among the growing volume of civilian traffic carried by satellite. The communications satellites that serve Latin America are more likely to be the targets of this expansion than Canadian satellites are, but any step towards the more systematic monitoring of civilian communications should be of concern. Who will be targeted next?

Recent Steps Toward Oversight

Unlike CSIS, which has the SIRC, CSE has never had any form of independent oversight organization to ensure that its invasive powers are not abused. In recent years, the establishment of an independent oversight committee has been recommended both by the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act and by the SIRC itself.[19] The response of the Mulroney government was that ``a broad accountability system for CSE is in place.''[20] This ``system,'' however, was no more than CSE's normal relationship with the officials at ICSI and DND who have responsibility for the SIGINT program. As the record of the RCMP Security Service, and later CSIS, demonstrated, intelligence agencies cannot be relied upon to police themselves.[21]

The Chretien government initially also maintained that CSE did not require independent oversight. To its credit, however, on 21 March 1995 it permitted the passage of a motion by MP Derek Lee calling on the government to ``establish an independent external mechanism to review the operations of the Communications Security Establishment, CSE, similar to the role played by the Security Intelligence Review Committee for the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, and table a report annually in the House.''[22] The following day, Defence Minister David Collenette announced that the government would indeed establish such a mechanism. He did not, however, provide any details of the government's plans, stating only that, ``in principle, the government supports an oversight mechanism for the CSE.''[23]

The above analysis suggests that a truly effective oversight mechanism would require:

A number of other reforms also would be useful, including: It remains to be seen whether the oversight mechanism to be established will be designed to oversee Canadian SIGINT activities or to overlook their use against Canadians. The government's record in fulfilling the above requirements should provide the answer to that question.

Endnotes

[1] Kevin O'Neill, ed., History of CBNRC, 1987, Chapter 2, Annex G (IAC SIGINT Memorandum No. 1, CONTROL OF SIGNAL INTELLIGENCE (SIGINT) IN CANADA, 24 August 1977), released in severed form under the Access to Information Act.

[2] For more information on Canada's wartime SIGINT activities, see John Bryden, Best-Kept Secret: Canadian Secret Intelligence in the Second World War, Lester Publishing, 1993.

[3] History of CBNRC, Chapter 17, p. 2.

[4] Ward Elcock, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Sub-Committee on National Security, 15 June 1993, p. 11:9; Statement by Margaret Bloodworth, Deputy Clerk, Security and Intelligence, to Standing Committee on National Defence and Veterans Affairs, 2 May 1995.

[5] Defence 90, Supply and Services, 1991, p. 48.

[6] On Course: National Security for the 1990s, Solicitor General, 1991, p. 54.

[7] History of CBNRC, Chapter 2, Annex G.

[8] Ward Elcock, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act, 24 April 1990, p. 27:9.

[9] History of CBNRC, Chapter 2, Annex G.

[10] On Course, p. 54.

[11] On Course, p. 54.

[12] Blair Seaborn, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act, 20 February 1990, p. 16:9.

[13] Quoted in Peter Moon, ``Spy agency left minister in dark,'' Globe and Mail, 3 June 1991, p. A4. Elsewhere Blais has commented that ``While I had responsibility for the estimates presented to Parliament, that responsibility did not extend to the exercise of ministerial control over the CSE. In practice the control was bureaucratic, in my view short-circuiting the principle of political accountability on which our democracy is founded.'' (Jean Jacques Blais, ``Committee should be expanded to review other agencies,'' Ottawa Citizen, 2 July 1992, p. A11.)

[14] History of CBNRC, Chapter 2, Annex G

[15] See, e.g., Minister of State (External Relations) Jean-Luc Pepin, testimony, Proceedings of the Special Committee of the Senate on the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, 22 September 1983, p. 19.

[16] Robert Kaplan, testimony, Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Standing Committee on Justice and Legal Affairs, 5 April 1984, p. 11:68.

[17] Letter from Commander F.B. Frewer, Director Public Affairs Operations, National Defence, to Peter Moon, 15 April 1991.

[18] Personal Information Index 1988, 1988, p. 47- 3.

[19] In Flux But Not in Crisis, report of the Special Committee on the Review of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service Act and the Security Offences Act, September 1990, pp. 152-3; Annual Report 1988-89, Security Intelligence Review Committee, 1989.

[20] On Course, p. 55.

[21] There is little reason to expect that CSE has been any more reliable in this respect. See, for example, the allegations in the book Spyworld (Mike Frost and Michel Gratton, Spyworld: Inside the Canadian and American Intelligence Establishments, Doubleday Canada, 1994) concerning the interception of Quebec government communications. In 1991, ``former CSE employees and other sources,'' told the Globe and Mail that ``in the past the agency routinely broke Canadian laws in the collection of intelligence involving Canadians.'' (Peter Moon, ``Secrecy shrouds spy agency,'' Globe and Mail, 27 May 1991, pp. A1, A4.) This allegation has not been proven, but a disquieting example of CSE failing to follow appropriate procedures and respect the rights of one of its own employees is on the public record in Muriel Korngold Wexler, Record of Decision (file 166-13-17850), Public Service Staff Relations Board, 12 March 1990. This document includes a detailed description of the mistreatment and eventual unjust firing of CSE cryptanalyst Edwina Slattery during the 1980s. It should be noted that Ms. Slattery considers the Record of Decision's description of the events surrounding her firing to be inaccurate in many respects, notwithstanding the fact that it supported her claim that she had been unjustly fired and recommended that she receive compensation equivalent to two years' pay. Ms. Slattery continues to pursue the case in the Federal Court of Canada.

[22] House of Commons Debates, 21 March 1995, pp. 10815-10820.

[23] Tu Thanh Ha, ``Secretive agency to be more open, Collenette says,'' Globe and Mail, 23 March 1995, p. A5.

Advanced TSCM Signals Detection and Analysis
TSCM - Sweeping the Spectrum for Eavesdropping Devices

Any comments or questions regarding this specific page?

Please feel free to sign our Guest Book

Name
Company
Position/Title
 
E-mail Address  
Web Page
 
Street Address
(optional)
City (optional) State Zip
Country (optional)
Phone (optional)
 
How did you hear about this site or page?
Do you need to have a bug sweep or other TSCM service performed?
Do you need any TSCM equipment?
 
Comments



| Home | What is TSCM | Types of Bugs | Warning Signs You're Bugged |
| How To Behave if Bugged | TSCM Threat Levels | How To Engage a TSCM Firm |
| Qualifications | TSCM Protocol | Bug Frequencies | Phone Taps and Bugging |
| Signal Analysis | TDR Analysis | TDR Tutorial | Wiretapping | Training | Tools |
| Equipment | OSC-5000 | Kaiser | Riser Bond | Avcom | Search Rcvrs |
| Outside Links | Recommended TSCM Books | TSCM Reference Library |
| Recommended U.S. TSCM Firms | TSCM-L Mailing List |


-----------------------

    To be contacted for a confidential consultation
    please E-mail: jmatk@tscm.com

    or send a letter via US Mail to:
    James M. Atkinson
    Granite Island Group
    127 Eastern Avenue #291
    Gloucester, MA 01931-8008

    or call:
    Telephone: (978) 546-3803 / Fax: (978) 546-9467

    URL: http://www.tscm.com/

Copyright ©2002, Granite Island Group